Planning a surprise party is a breeze with Alyssa and Maria’s help. Alyssa insists on talking to me every time she’s with Eric and she gives me Alcide’s number so I can get things going with Maria. The tricky part is making sure all of the kids will be there, but Levi promises to play enforcer, if need be, and get all of his brothers to Alcide’s for the party.
It turns out he really is seeing someone new, and I’m happy for him. He’s bringing her to the party so Eric can meet her. I think it’s best for everyone that Levi found a new girl.
For a hot minute I think about inviting Jessica to come but decide against it since Eric’s kids are going to be there. I do make travel plans to drive in two days before the party to help Maria with the last minute stuff. The tricky part will be keeping Eric from finding out I’m in town. After more than three weeks apart I know the first thing he’s going to do when he sees me is tear my clothes off.
Phone sex is fun once or twice, but after that you want the real thing and it’s getting harder and harder to go back to California alone. On the bright side, Eric doesn’t know that I’m flying ahead to Arizona the day before him so I’ll already be at the hotel when he lands. Turns out I’m good at being sneaky. Of course it helps that we aren’t living together.
When I get back to Utah it’s good to see Maria and Alcide again and Alcide is quick to comment about how it’s good I’m back because Eric’s been ‘a grumpy bitch’ since I left. I probably haven’t been much better, but I’ve been surprisingly busy with all of my planning. I help Maria get their house set up and we grocery shop a few towns over so there’s less chance of Eric spotting me before I want him to.
Two days before the party I put on one of my little sundresses and a cardigan because there’s a chill in the air. I don’t bother with panties and head over to Eric’s apartment. I call him when I’m pulling up so he can meet me downstairs.
“I’m here,” I tell him.
“I’ll be down in a minute,” he says.
“I’ll be waiting,” I say, and hang up.
I get the car parked and pull my bags from the trunk. In addition to my regular stuff, I brought a few things from my toy chest for us to play with. The kids won’t be coming back to the apartment with us after the party, but we’re planning on dinner with all of them the next night since it will officially be Eric’s birthday. I’m just closing the trunk when he appears all sexy and fresh from the shower.
He doesn’t even have a shirt on. If I wasn’t wet before, I am now.
“Okay I know you have a thing for public sex, but this is definitely too public,” I tell him as he approaches me.
“Just foreplay, baby,” he winks and leans down to kiss me. “Hello,” he murmurs against my lips.
“Hi,” I say back and discreetly guide his hand under my skirt. “I came prepared.”
“You have ten seconds to get in the house otherwise I won’t be held accountable for what I do you,” he growls as his finger rubs over my clit.
I whimper but force myself to pull away and make a run for it. I’m sure he’s serious and the heavy footsteps behind me only confirm it. I’m barely inside the apartment when Eric catches up with me as the door slams shut behind us.
I’m so tempted to tell him I’ve been in town for the last two days but he would want to know why and it would spoil everything so I keep it to myself.
“I don’t know why you just showered. We’ll end up back in there soon,” I say as Eric attacks my neck with kisses.
“It was for your benefit,” he chuckles against my skin. “I just got done working out… we should’ve just fucked in the shower.”
“I’m sure we will before I go home.” I turn around so I’m facing him and his lips crash down on mine. He picks me up by my thighs and pins me against the nearest wall.
“I hope you’re not expecting magic right now. I’ve gone too long without you and it’s going to be quick,” he warns.
His hips flex, rubbing his growing erection against my pussy. Eric already has my skirt up around my hips so I’m completely bare and ready for him.
“I like quick. Quick feels great after missing you for three weeks.”
“Mmm,” he hums. “Good…” he trails off when my mouth reaches his Adams apple and I suck lightly. “Jesus, I’m going to cum before I get inside of you.”
“Then quit stalling,” I say, and bite him gently.
He reaches between our bodies and pushes his shorts down just enough to get his cock out. He rubs his head through my slit and I feel him smile against my lips when he feels how wet I am. I’ve been waiting for this for weeks, so I’m very ready.
“Ready?” he asks when his tip starts to push into me.
“Very,” I nod.
His tongue plunges into my mouth at the same time his cock drives into my pussy. He’s so into the kiss he doesn’t move though. Eric holds onto my ass a little tighter and staggers back. We fall to the loveseat and his hands slide up my back and thread into my hair.
I start grinding against him and he groans into the kiss. When I begin moving up and down he breaks the kiss and pulls my dress up over my head to get it off of me.
“I’ve missed the girls,” he groans and pulls the cups of my bra down. His lips attach to my nipple and he starts to suck.
“Mmm… they missed you too.” I swivel my hips and slam down.
“Again,” he breathes and moves to my other breast. His hands are holding onto my ass with a tight grip.
I repeat the move, and then start riding him hard. Fuck, it feels so good.
“The magic cock is going to have his grand finale soon,” Eric jokes, and then let’s his head drop back. “Oh, this pussy is too fucking good.”
I’m close too but I want him to cum first because he rarely ever does, so I reach behind me and gently rub his balls.
“So… good…” he pants, “More, make me cum, pretty.”
I squeeze a little more and grind against him. My head falls back and all of a sudden my orgasm sneaks up on me and I explode. We’re talking flashing lights behind my eyes and everything. So. Fucking. Good.
I’m so lost in my moment I don’t even notice Eric cumming, but when I come to he’s sagging against the back of the loveseat.
“I’ve missed you,” he pants, “Like really missed you.”
“I really missed you too,” I pant and lean against him.
“What do you want to do? I have a few days off for my birthday,” he says and rubs up and down my back.
“I don’t know. We already have plans for two of our days together. I brought some of my toys with me for us to play with,” I tell him.
“That leaves today and tomorrow morning for stupid amounts of sex to make up for lost time,” he grins. “What toys did you bring?”
“My handcuffs, the blindfold, the birthday paddle and a few other things…” I trail off. I want to try something new with him that I know he’ll love if he can just be open enough to trying it.
“What aren’t you telling me?” he asks as his hands smooth down my back to my ass.
“I was thinking we could try something different but I’m not sure how you would feel about it even though I promise you it will be the best orgasm you’ve ever had.”
“Sookie,” he says my name nervously. “I trust you, but you’re making me nervous.”
I pull back a little bit so I can look into his eyes. “Have you ever heard of a prostate orgasm?”
“Yes…” he nods. “What are you suggesting?”
“I’m suggesting that I brought a toy designed to do that and I thought we could try using it together.”
He’s silent for a long time and then he finally looks like he’s made a decision. “We can try it…”
“Really? Are you sure?” I’m surprised he’s agreeing even though I know he’ll love it.
“No,” he laughs, “But you take everything I give you… and what if I like it?”
“If you like it then we found a way for me to give you a special treat. Without getting into details, the guys I’ve talked to that have done this all said that once they started cumming it felt like it was never going to stop,” I tell him. “Who doesn’t want to feel like they’re never going to stop cumming?”
“That does sound good… what’s the best orgasm you’ve had?” he asks, his voice dropping an octave and thrusts his hips up. I can feel his cock twitching inside of me.
“Mmm… That’s hard to decide. I’ve had a lot of good ones,” I say. I don’t want to placate him but I don’t want to say the best I ever had was with someone else either.
“Well then what’s the best you’ve had since we’ve been serious? I like knowing what’s good to you.”
I think about it for a moment before I answer. I have a lot to choose from. Sex with Eric is never dull or monotonous.
“My best was the morning you left my place. I honestly don’t remember ever cumming that hard before,” I say sincerely.
“Is there anything you want me to do again? I like making you feel good,” he says and thrusts up again.
“And you do,” I assure him. “I really don’t know if there’s anything you could do to replicate that. It wasn’t just the mechanics it was the emotional stuff too. There was this connection and it felt so intense.”
He slides his hand up to the back of my head, pulls my face to his and whispers, “Well what do you want right now because I plan on keeping you naked for the rest of the night.”
“You. I just want you.” I honestly don’t care how I have him as long as I do.
“Good answer,” he replies and I can feel him getting harder inside of me. “I’ll even spank you for my birthday later,” he grins and nips my bottom lip.
“I don’t think that’s the way it’s supposed to go,” I smile, and start to rock back and forth slowly.
“It’s my day and I want to spank you. Are you saying the birthday boy doesn’t get what he wants?”
“Okay, but just remember this rule when my birthday comes around next year.”
“Nope,” he shakes his head no and holds my hips in place so he can grind up into me.
I groan but then say, “Then forget it. You can spank yourself.”
“Nope, all the spankings are for you,” he smirks and helps me rock my hips again.
“Not if I cuff you.”
“Mmm, I’ve been such a good boy though.” Eric’s hard enough now that I can start to move up and down so I sit up and drop down.
“Exactly,” I smirk.
He doesn’t respond, instead he unhooks my bra and slides it down my arms. As it goes flying across the room his lips wrap around my nipple and one of his hands finds my clit. He’s tracing light circles and he releases my nipple to tell me, “I’ll let you do whatever you want to do to me.”
“Smart boy.” I wrap my arms around his neck and kiss him hard.
Eric startles me when he stands up while holding me. His cock falls out and his fingers wiggle toward my center.
“Ready for play time?” he asks as his middle finger rubs over my drenched opening.
“Which toys do you want to play with?” I ask.
“Surprise me,” he says as he sets me on my feet.
“With any of them?” I quirk an eyebrow.
He looks a little nervous when he replies, “With any, yes…”
“We don’t have to do it if you aren’t comfortable with it. I don’t want you to do it for me.”
“Sookie,” he cups my face and kisses my lips and then says, “I trust you, I love you and if you promise it’ll be worth it, then I’ll do it. Now I’m going to lay on the bed ready for you to do your worst.”
With that he kisses me one more time, drops his shorts and then walks toward the bedroom, giving me a little more sway in his hips with his best impression of me. He’s adorable.
I can’t help but laugh and get my bag of tricks from the entryway. Just like he said he would be, Eric is stretched out on his bed, stroking himself while he waits for me. I set the bag on the edge of the bed and pull the zipper. It takes a few seconds to find the toy I want and when I do I hand it to Eric so he can inspect it.
“If you twist the slim end it’ll start vibrating,” I tell him.
“Is that good?” he asks as he turns it on.
“You tell me. If you don’t like it we don’t have to turn it on.” I pull a bottle of lube from my bag.
“How do we do this? I have a feeling it’ll be awkward,” he laughs. “Do you really like phallic things shoved in your ass?”
“Are you really asking me this after we’ve had anal sex how many times?”
“True,” he says and flicks it on and off again. “I’ve had shits bigger than this, so I’m sure it’ll be fine.”
“I love it when you talk dirty to me,” I deadpan.
“Sorry,” he laughs. “I’m blaming it on the nerves.”
I put the bag on the floor and climb up on the bed so I’m kneeling between his thighs. I rub his legs, hoping he’ll relax a bit.
“I’m going to take care of you, I promise. If you’re uncomfortable or you don’t like it just tell me and we’ll stop, okay?”
“I know you’ll be good to me,” he says softly and strokes his cock a few more times. “Kiss me first,” he says and motions toward his tip.
She leans down, resting her hands on my thighs. She allows me to guide my tip between her lips and she keeps her eyes on mine as she sucks lightly. While she’s sucking she shifts and I’m not paying attention to what she’s doing until I hear the lube open and a few seconds later Sookie’s finger rubs light circles over my asshole making me tense.
Her head lifts and she strokes me as she says, “Try to relax. Trust me when I tell you that if you’re tense it won’t feel good.”
“I’m trying,” I say and cup my balls, caressing them while I grab my shaft under her hand so we can stroke together.
Sookie keeps her eyes on mine and our hands work together while she plays with an area that’s never really been played with before. She takes her time with it, checking in with me to make sure she’s not going too fast. When I’m as sure as I’m ever going to be about being ready to go further Sookie stops stroking my cock and bows her head to swirl her tongue around my head. Her hair creates a golden curtain so I can’t really see what her hands are doing.
I feel the slight pressure of the toy pressing against what I had always deemed as an exit only area, and she gently pushes it in. Sookie’s got it lubed up good and her tongue on the head of my cock almost makes me forget what else she’s doing to me.
That is until the toy finds the magic spot. It’s like a jolt of electricity goes through me.
“Oh my fuck,” I groan, low and deep in my throat.
Sookie moves the toy back and forth, running over that same spot over and over.
“Should I try turning the vibrator on?” she asks.
“Mmm… mmhmm,” I hum. I don’t know how I feel about enjoying this, but it’s… if it gets any better I’m in trouble.
She stops moving the toy and I see her hands move right before the toy starts vibrating.
“Oh wow,” I breathe as she rubs over the spot.
But she doesn’t stop there. Sookie moves the toy in a slow and gentle way while her mouth goes to work on my cock. There she’s not playing, and she takes me as deep down her throat as she can.
I feel my orgasm approaching and I can’t say anything. My fingers weave into her hair, holding her so my cock stays deep down her throat and all I can do is whimper.
“Ah… fuck… I…”
Sookie hums and that’s it. There’s no holding it back. I make noises I’ve never made before and just like she said once I start cumming it feels like it’s never going to stop. It’s the most intense pleasure I’ve ever felt and I’ve felt some pretty amazing pleasure since I met Sookie.
Her head keeps bobbing up and down on my cock until I go limp. I can’t think; I can’t move… I can hardly breathe.
Sookie’s soft tongue licks the cum off my balls that leaked out of her hot little mouth, and she turns the vibrator off.
All I can do is watch her when she removes the toy and sets it to the side.
“If you’re going to tie me up, I can’t resist right now,” I say when she sits up on her knees between my legs.
“No, I’m going to let you catch your breath. I don’t want to kill you,” she says, and moves so she’s lying beside me. “Was it good?”
“Mmm, I don’t think good is the right word.”
“The pint of cum I just swallowed would suggest I’m oversimplifying.”
“So you’re saying you aren’t hungry?” I joke.
“Not anymore,” she snorts.
“Yes, good is oversimplifying. That was intense.”
“Did you like it?” she asks nervously.
“I did. I won’t say I want it all the time, but it would be fun every now and then. Mainly because I don’t think my heart would hold out,” I laugh.
“Well then this will be something you ask for,” she says. “And you’re not that old.”
I still don’t think I can move, which is a bit scary. “I feel old since I still can’t move.”
Sookie shifts so she’s straddling my waist and leans down so we’re eye to eye.
“You are not old,” she says. “You’ll start moving again and when you do it will be so you can thank me for rocking your world.”
“I don’t have to move if you just sit on my face and ride my tongue,” I purr.
“I can do that. Is that what you want?”
“Mmhmm, it’s been too long since I’ve tasted you,” I say and tilt my head up to kiss her.
She kisses me back while rocking her hips so I can feel how wet she is.
“Come on, let me taste her, baby girl,” I whisper and Sookie grins.
She gets up on her hands and knees before crawling up my body. She shifts so her feet are on either side of my head. Her hands are on the headboard and she’s squatting so her pussy is just out of reach. I finally feel like I can move my arms and I reach up to wrap my arms around her legs so I can pull her down. As soon as I can reach my tongue slides through her lips from her opening to her clit and I flick a few times before repeating my actions.
Sookie starts to rock her hips and I use my thumbs to hold her open and swirl my tongue around her clit.
“Mmm… baby, that feels so good,” Sookie moans and grinds against me.
“Do you want my fingers?” I ask. “Or just my tongue.”
“Just your tongue,” she says.
I hum and snake my tongue down to her opening. I use my flattened tongue to lick her, dipping in just a little so I can taste myself inside of her. She’s soaking wet right now, her honey coating my mouth, dripping down my jaw is so fucking hot. I might get hard again while I lick her. I want to shove my fingers into her so bad, but she said tongue only so she gets tongue. The back and forth between her swollen nub and her dripping hole has her legs trembling.
She moves off of my tongue so she can reposition. Her knees are next to my head now and she’s rocking faster over my tongue. She tastes so good, so hot and sticky. Sookie does a pretty good job of fucking herself on my tongue, and when I know she’s close I grab her hips and hold her still so I can suck on her clit until she does.
“Ohmygod, Eric!” she cries out when her orgasm hits, and my tongue slides back to her opening to lap up the fresh honey pouring from her.
Her whole body is vibrating as she falls to the side, nearly kicking me in the head.
“You okay over there?” I ask from my spot. Sookie’s head is by my hip and her feet are on the headboard.
“Now I can’t move,” she says.
“We’re two peas in a pod,” I laugh. “I need a snack and then we’ll fuck all night. I think I saw you pulling some other fun things out of your bag.”
“You probably did. And that wasn’t even the bag with my costumes in it,” she smiles.
“Sookie,” I groan, “You plan on making this the best birthday ever don’t you?”
“I honestly don’t know how I’ll top myself next year,” she sighs.
“All I ask is that you’re still around next year,” I say and try to sit up. No go, I fall right back again.
“I don’t plan on going anywhere,” she says, and kisses my leg. “Well, that’s not entirely true.”
“Oh yeah? Where are you going?”
Sookie manages to turn herself around so she’s got her chin on my chest. “I’ve been thinking a lot about moving. I’m tired of missing you.”
“I’m tired of missing you too,” I say and run my fingers through her hair. “We can get a bigger place if you move here.”
“Eventually we probably should, but I think we would be okay here for a while. I’m not going to sell my house so I won’t be bringing much more than my clothes,” she says.
“We’ll need a room just for your shoes,” I chuckle. “That would be the best birthday present though, you agreeing to be here full-time.”
“I can put my shoes in Alyssa’s closet. Our feet are the same size,” she informs me. “And is that really what you want for your birthday?”
“Yes; do you have something better to offer?”
She shakes her head. “I don’t think so. I think for now that’s my top offer.”
“Then I accept,” I nod and pull her face up to mine so I can kiss her.